• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The River

The personal professional blog of Pamela Parker -- musings on marketing, advertising, media and technology.

  • Home
  • About/Contact
    • Disclosure
  • Categories
    • Technology
    • Marketing
      • Advertising
    • Media
    • Blogging
    • Search

Search

In Defense of SEO

November 4, 2023 by Pamela Parker

I’m not a search engine optimization (SEO) professional, but I know a lot of them. I’ve been lucky enough to attend dozens of search-related conferences (from Search Engine Strategies back in the day to SMX more recently), and, in the course of this, I’ve met some very talented, well-spoken, down-to-earth good people.

If you’re wondering why SEO (the practice) and SEOs (the people) are in need of defense, you probably haven’t read the Verge article posted a few days ago. Or Danny Sullivan’s reaction. To be honest, I haven’t read either of them in full, but after a few paragraphs like those I’ve pasted below, I was moved to write. This hasn’t happened to me in a long time, so I thought I’d express some of that passion (and reason) here.

A few choice phrases from the piece in question:

The links that pop up when they go looking for answers online, they say, are “absolutely unusable”; “garbage”; and “a nightmare” because “a lot of the content doesn’t feel authentic.” Some blame Google itself, asserting that an all-powerful, all-seeing, trillion-dollar corporation with a 90 percent market share for online search is corrupting our access to the truth. But others blame the people I wanted to see in Florida, the ones who engage in the mysterious art of search engine optimization, or SEO.

Doing SEO is less straightforward than buying the advertising space labeled “Sponsored” above organic search results; it’s more like the Wizard of Oz projecting his voice to magnify his authority. The goal is to tell the algorithm whatever it needs to hear for a site to appear as high up as possible in search results, leveraging Google’s supposed objectivity to lure people in and then, usually, show them some kind of advertising.

Perhaps this is why nearly everyone hates SEO and the people who do it for a living: the practice seems to have successfully destroyed the illusion that the internet was ever about anything other than selling stuff.

Everyone hates SEO and the people who do it for a living?

I certainly don’t, and my viewpoint on these folks and their profession is much more well-informed than one could possibly gain by observing things from afar and then attending a single conference. Sure, there are bad actors, but to tar the whole profession would be like saying all lawyers are bad because some are unethical. (Bad example?)

Most people who do SEO are just looking to get their business, or their client’s business, visibility on the internet. They work with retailers or pediatric dentists or farm-to-table restaurants or mom-and-pop run car washes. They work with everyone. If you’re publishing on the internet and you’re not doing SEO, you’re doing something wrong. Because SEO is just following best practices — and the best practice of all is creating good, useful content that interests and benefits your target audience — to help Google discover (and therefore rank) your content high when people are looking for what you offer.

As you might imagine, those who publish on the internet are also no strangers to SEO. Since I’ve worked in internet publishing ever since it’s been a thing (I launched this site in 1995), I’ve gotten a behind-the-scenes look at what people do to improve their rankings and it’s not mumbo jumbo. Amanda Chicago Lewis, in the Verge article, compares SEO to doing a rain dance or ritual sacrifice. It’s not that. As many people told her for the piece, it’s a lot of hard work. It takes time and effort to develop great content, make sure your site is organized in a logical way and get pages to load as quickly as possible. Especially when you’ve got years of content online.

Is business always bad?

Here’s what it comes down to, though — your fundamental perspective on the nature of business. Why do I think this? Another line from the article:

And as much as I might hate the way the SEOs who don’t follow Google’s rules have altered my online experience, the reality is that most people running a company will break whatever rules they are able to get away with breaking.

To me, that’s crazy talk. Let me say that again.

…Most people running a company will break whatever rules they are able to get away with breaking.

Really? Just because someone’s trying to make a buck — or even lots of bucks — that doesn’t mean they are evil. If you believe it does, there’s really nothing I can say to change your mind. Call me a Pollyanna, but I’ve met lots of smart, honest, well-intended SEOs. Even the article admits that the days of easy money in the space are over, and the sleaziest of the lot have moved on to easier, more lucrative pursuits.

I also believe Google does a good job in an increasingly complex environment, though it will need to be continually working to deliver better results. No, it’s not perfect, and the challenges facing it are only growing in a generative AI-powered world, but I don’t think there’s anything nefarious going on. Others will disagree.

Filed Under: Marketing, Media, Search

The Future Of Search And Digital – notes from the Local Social Event

November 11, 2014 by Pamela Parker

Loren_Baker_Local_Social_20141
No, I’m not asleep. Just resting my eyes, I’m sure.

In preparation for speaking at the Local Social event in Dallas last month, I wrote up thoughts on a few emerging areas that I think will have a big impact on digital marketing, and marketing as a whole, in the coming years. In the spirit of “leveraging content” I’ll publish them here…

One of the most interesting areas we’ve been exploring — and this is a big area, admittedly — is the intersection between the real world and the digital world, sometimes called augmented reality.

When you think about it, we live in the real world and the digital world is just a reflection of that. Why should we have to be tethered to a certain screen at a desk at home to see that digital world, when it’s so much more useful when it’s integrated into our daily lives? We’ve gotten a little taste of that with smartphones, but we’re still mostly looking into a world that’s totally different than the world around us — watching videos, checking Facebook and email — which is one reason why smartphones are criticized as being harmful to society and human relationships.

The Physical Web

We recently published a piece on Marketing Land by Daniel Cristo looking at an open-source project initiated by Google called “The Physical Web.”

The gist of the Physical Web project is that, given there are so many real-world objects — refrigerators, slow cookers, thermostats, etc. — that are now connected and possess digital information, that there should be a way to search and find all of them, and they should be ranked by your personalized level of interest in that particular thing.

This is starting to happen now, where when I go near a Walgreens, a notification pops up on my phone with my loyalty card and a link to the week’s specials, and when I’m near my local grocery store, I get a notification from my Ibotta app reminding me to use their coupons. All of this, of course, is permission-based.

Imagine when we’re wearing Google Glass or Apple Watch, and we can pay for things by waving our devices. And of course, we’ll be wearing our heart-rate-tracking monitors,  pedometers and glucose monitors — sharing, or not sharing, the information they’re gathering. So maybe, as a marketer, you could learn whether someone’s heart starts racing when they come into contact with your products or your ads.

Meanwhile, we’re seeing an amazing proliferation of tracking devices, most of them using Bluetooth Low Energy and some using GPS and Wi-fi. The obvious use — already happening with Apple’s iBeacons — is messaging customers when they’re in proximity of your store. Or, in an even more granular application, marketers could virtually show people around a store, and passively observe what aisles are most popuar with different types of consumers — data which can then inform merchandising and future marketing campaigns.

According to ABI Research, indoor beacon installations could top 30,000 worldwide by the end of 2014. We’re already seeing things like an in store proximity based mobile ad exchange, where a brand could pop up a notification when you approach its product display at a retail outlet.

Maybe the next wave of content/experiential marketing is curating a real-world walking tour or sponsoring a complimentary entry into a museum exhibit for a valued prospect or customer.

And brick and mortar marketers aren’t the only ones deploying these trackers. You’ve probably seen consumer-focused Facebook ads or Kickstarter campaigns for the Tile, StickNFind, Duet, Chipolo, Gecko, Lapa and Guardian. The most common pitch here is that they’ll ensure you never lose your keys, your wallet, your pet or your child. Other variations like Flower Power and Plant Link check whether you need to water your plants and how much light they’re getting, and possibly even open a valve to get a sprinkler going.

Data Overload!

And you thought you were overwhelmed by the amount of data you’re dealing with now!

That leads me to another area where I’m seeing a lot of promise — tag management. It’s sort of outgrown that moniker but the idea is that you can have a central interface to all of those tags that live on your web site — analytics, ad networks, remarketing lists, a/b testing, etc. etc.

The beauty in this is that all of the data flows into one place, too, making it easier for you to change vendors perform tests, because you have access to all your customer and prospect data yourself. In addition, you can get a more cross-platform picture of your customer, when information about their interactions with email can be married to their location history and even an Apple Pay-enabled transaction record.

We’ve seen a lot of consolidation in the marketing technology business lately, partly by big companies set on building an end-to-end solution that uses and shares the same data in multiple marketing disciplines. But with tag management, theoretically, you could choose best of breed solutions in each of their respective categories, yet still control and integrate the data.

Seeking Marketing Technologists

Of course, I’m talking in a very blasé way about technology that’s going to take some serious smarts to deploy and use well, especially given the need to respect consumer privacy. And that’s not to mention the challenge of choosing the right technologies among so many competitors.

And that brings me to the third area, which is the important need in our industry of hiring and training marketing technologists — those rare birds that not only understand the needs of marketers and consumers, but also “get” technology at a bit of a deeper level.

This is going to be a huge challenge but also a big opportunity for those individuals who have the skills to really take advantage of the vast array of tools at our disposal — but in a clear-headed, and not starry-eyed way.

P.S. I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention that the event was a fundraiser for traumatic brain injury support charity Trymunity. Given the prevalence of TBI in all of our lives — concussions among football players, strokes, etc. (I’ve had two people close to me have strokes in the last month) — I believe it’s a critical issue that should be supported. 

Filed Under: Marketing, Search, Speaking

Speaking In The Next Month

September 29, 2014 by Pamela Parker

Banner 600 (2)

It’s going to be a busy few weeks — and it’s already started!

Tomorrow, SMX East begins in NYC, and it’s still possible to register on site — or get free expo passes that include admission to certain sessions.

Then, next month (which is coming up rapidly), I’ll be in the Dallas area with some notable industry figures for the Local Social one-day event, benefiting traumatic brain injury research.

More to come, but hope to see you somewhere!

Filed Under: Search, Social, Speaking

Back From SMX West 2014

March 14, 2014 by Pamela Parker

I arrived home last night this morning after a whirlwind beginning to the conference season — starting with SXSW Interactive, which had to be interrupted midstream for a trip to San Jose for our company’s own conference, SMX West.

I don’t know what it was about this year’s show — maybe our inaugural Marketing Land Digital Marketing Summit — but I came away from the show with such a good feeling. I loved socializing with people, meeting columnists I hadn’t met before in person, and seeing long-time industry friends again. Additionally, the panelists for the sessions I moderated did such a good job and had such interesting and valuable things to share.

So I thought I’d take the opportunity to share the live blogs and slides from my sessions here.

“Life After Not Provided” explored the options for measuring success (and fixing problems) in a world where we no longer have access to keyword data in analytics platforms.

  • Here’s a live blog from Chelsea Adams at Bruce Clay Inc.
  •  Benjamin Spiegel’s presentation (he’s the director of search operations at Catalyst)
  • Marty Weintraub’s slides (he’s founder and evangelist of aimClear)
  • Ken Shults (of Global Strategies) and Laura Ann Mitchell (of Intel)’s tag-team preso.

“Pro-Level Tips For Succeeding At Retargeting” covered a few different approaches and platforms (Google search, GDN, FSLA, FBX and a technique that uses LinkedIn) to successful retargeting.

  • Here’s coverage from Janet Driscoll Miller on the Marketing Mojo Blog
  • 3Q Digital’s Jay Stampfl’s presentation covering Google-centric approaches.
  • John Hamilton from Triggit shared insights related to the Facebook Exchange
  • Tad Miller from Marketing Mojo covered approaches that work for B2B companies, or others with a long sales cycle and a need to qualify prospects.

Filed Under: Journalism, Marketing, Search

SXSW Interactive: Beyond The Hype

March 5, 2014 by Pamela Parker

sxsw-squareAs much as people love SXSW, there’s definitely a backlash. Some blame the conference for the ever-growing tide of immigrants to Austin, which is stressing infrastructure and heightening fears about water shortages. Others decry it as just another tech conference, or bemoan the hipster factor. (Can you tell I’m a local now?)

I see more and more people tweeting with dread (myself among them) rather than excitement about the event, so it seems we all need to take it down a notch.

Remember that, at heart, SXSW is still a “festival” — not a conference. Where else would you find panel discussions on things like: “Making More of Ourselves – Sensory & Multimodal UX,” “Unearthing the Atari Graveyard: The Search for ET,” and, um, “Orgasm: The Broadband of Human Connection“? (Heck, there’s even a Ping Pong Tournament.) [Read more…] about SXSW Interactive: Beyond The Hype

Filed Under: Advertising, Current Affairs, Marketing, Media, Mobile, Search, Social, Social Media, Technology

Troubleshooting Google Authorship Issues

November 8, 2013 by Pamela Parker

How to ensure your mug appears next to stuff you wrote, on Google search results.

How

Filed Under: Marketing, Search, Social

  • Go to page 1
  • Go to page 2
  • Go to page 3
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Go to page 6
  • Go to Next Page »

Primary Sidebar

Follow me on Twitter

Follow @pamelaparker

Categories

Archives

My Twitter Feed

Tweets by @pamelaparker

Footer

© 2025 · The River · Built on the Genesis Framework